https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/secretive-nhs-fife-lodge-legal-35029201
Secretive NHS Fife has been blasted after lodging a legal bid attempting to block the public from viewing the conclusion of the Sandie Peggie employment tribunal. The case is set to restart in July after commencing in February, with the delay the result of the health board refusing to hand over key documents.
And now the health board want to ban the public from watching the live stream of the case, and also stop Tribunal Tweets from live-tweeting it as it claims there have been "inaccuracies" in the coverage. Judge Kemp will decide on this in a behind closed doors summit on Tuesday, April 15.
It garnered a lot of public attention and the live stream of the tribunal was well attended by journalists and the general public. However, the health board now wants to restrict "virtual viewing" of it so only journalists can get access when it restarts in July. NHS Fife claimed that the first stage of the tribunal was marred by "technical issues and interruptions" from people watching online, which it said caused "significant delays" to proceedings. In September, the health board and Dr Upton sought an order to hold it in private and prevent the publication of the doctor's name, citing concerns about their health and safety. But this was rejected on the grounds that the issues were involved were of legitimate public debate and that open justice must be upheld. Issues were reported with the livestream due to the technology involved as it was similar to a conference call, meaning that observers had to mute their microphones and switch off cameras or risk impacting proceedings, which did happen a number of times.
The health board also want a ban on Tribunal Tweets posting live updates, claiming it had received a public complaint about the posts. It said: "Our legal team at the Central Legal Office carried out an analysis of the tweets, and found a number of inaccuracies. Following this review, a request was therefore made to the Tribunal to revoke Tribunal Tweets' permission to live-tweet proceedings, on the grounds that reporting must be 'fair and accurate."
Scottish Tory Shadow Equalities Minister Tess White criticised this attempt to make the case private. She said: "This reeks of an attempt at secrecy and cover-up from NHS Fife. There is understandably huge public interest in this case, yet this health board are trying to find any excuse from keeping it out of view from the public.
“The public will be appalled at NHS Fife’s latest actions given they are squandering taxpayers’ money on this case at a time when frontline healthcare services are in crisis locally. The health board should rethink this request, allow time for any technical issues to be resolved by the tribunal and let people tune into the next stage of this tribunal without any restrictions.”