I have #aphantasia and I can’t make visual images in my head. ‘Picture an apple’.. I can’t picture anything. People have asked me how I dream. I don’t have visual dreams.
I just had a dream in which I.. smelled a variety of things. Interesting!
I have #aphantasia and I can’t make visual images in my head. ‘Picture an apple’.. I can’t picture anything. People have asked me how I dream. I don’t have visual dreams.
I just had a dream in which I.. smelled a variety of things. Interesting!
@mloxton yes, i never have visual dreams. it's all the other senses
@skinnylatte
wait, you smelled something in a dream?
@screwturn sure. email me: skinnylatte [ at ] gmail
i read extensively, a lot of fiction too.
scifi and fantasy fiction is very difficult for me to parse and follow. i almost always have to look up illustrations to help me. but if the writing is good i am able to just 'feel' it anyway
@skinnylatte
Writer here.
I am very curious what goes on with you when you read one of my short stories.
May I offer you a link to one?
@skinnylatte @mloxton How do you identify what things you're smelling without vision?
@msbellows @mloxton i have no way of understanding how people process thoughts through vision, so this is just totally normal for me.
in tihs dream, i was probably walking into a crowded old timey bar and i smelled cigarette smoke. instead of 'seeing' the bar' or the place, i simply only smelled the smoke and other people. it's as if the vision part of it was just missing.
@skinnylatte I used to work for a company that treated this sort of thing with various visualization and verbalization techniques. I saw some pretty amazing things during my time there.
@skinnylatte @mloxton Wow. Fascinating.
@msbellows @mloxton in real life, i have the vision piece only in the present: when i am actively seeing the thing. so i can process sight and smell in real time. but once i walk away i can no longer conjure the visual in my head but i can still 'smell' if i try
@shansterable there's a term for that. hyperphantasia! lots of people who get it get extremely disturbed by the visuals
@skinnylatte
I find this extremely interesting.
I am the opposite. I picture pretty much everything that is said to me. That is why I have a lot of trouble when people use pronouns without first identifying the noun - a big blank comes to my mind as the subject of the sentence.
This is also why I cannot tolerate phrases such as "Let me pick your brain" as I see in my mind a dental-style pick poking at my open skull. Ew!
@ShiitakeToast @shansterable yeah i can't visualize anything
@shansterable @skinnylatte hang on a minute! That’s not normal?!
@skinnylatte
Learned a new word today. Thanks!
And, yes, many visuals are extremely disturbing.
Flogging a dead horse: someone standing over a dead, rotting horse repeatedly using a bullwhip.
Kill two birds with one stone: Someone holding a large stone and smashing two birds into bloody mush.
On and on....
@ShiitakeToast @shansterable not really. i also do not have an inner voice or monologue haha
@skinnylatte @shansterable what about sounds? If I say nails on a chalkboard, do you hear anything?
@ShiitakeToast @shansterable although because i play music i can 'hear' pitch and tones quite well in my head, i just maybe tune out all stimuli when i'm walking across anything
@adammoe2022 oh yes I’ve read about some people who have taught themselves to ‘ses’
@skinnylatte I once worked with a surgeon that couldn’t picture and discuss performing an operation and needed to pass an oral board to be certified. It worked. Frankly, it was pretty amazing work.
@negative12dollarbill I would need an actual printed reference image of photo.
@skinnylatte
What if I asked you to draw an apple? Could you do that?
@ShiitakeToast @shansterable my internal monologue is exactly like how I write (here and long form). Like a long form essay of text and feelings.
It actually kind of colors the way I write because I can ‘feel’ the quality of sentences and emotions
@skinnylatte @shansterable jealous about the lack of inner monologue, unless it just comes out externally.
@airwhale yep that is hyperphantasia! no idea what that's like!
I'm almost 60 and I had never heard of this before right now. Mind blown and I am finding it super fascinating. I am also very opposite - a very visual thinker and my dreams often have Hollywood level production for the sets (although the writers are crap). I even had dreams with rolling end credits.
Then again, I have a very limited sense of smell. Weird…
Thanks for sharing!
GNU social JP is a social network, courtesy of GNU social JP管理人. It runs on GNU social, version 2.0.2-dev, available under the GNU Affero General Public License.
All GNU social JP content and data are available under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 license.