@evan OK, so the people who were surprised to see their posts being boosted โ that likely happened because their instance was subscribed to one of these public relays?
@evan Thanks. I think this is all important nuance thatโs being lost. It seems like most people think this was a blind scraper.
At worst, the tags.pub documentation did not make clear enough that posts it saw โ posts it was *specifically given permission to use* by instance admins or users โ would be sent to relays, or which relays those were.
(That is, if Iโm still understanding all this correctly, which I may not be.)
1. Instance admin connects to tags.pub relay 2. Instance user posts a hashtag 3. tags.pub sees the post and boosts it 4. The boost is sent to other, potentially objectionable instances through the public relays
Is that right?
That still seems โopt-in,โ but through the actions of the instance admin rather than the user. *Somebody* related to the user/instance did take *some action* that resulted in these posts being sent to the relays.
tags.pub didnโt proactively go out and start scraping these posts without having been told about them.
@evan So the people who were surprised to see this โ was their instance relaying with tags.pub? Or was their instance relaying with another relay that connected to tags.pub?
@evan How was tags.pub boosting posts from people who hadnโt followed its follow back bot? Is relaying your instance with tags.pub equivalent to having all your users follow the follow back bot?
> tags.pub is now unsubscribed from the open registration relay servers it was previously using.
Hm Iโm confused about this. What were these relay servers specifically and why was tags.pub using them? And how did this result in posts being visible in ways that surprised users?
@stevenbodzin@anildash@Aaronvegh Things will continue to get worse as long as people writing pieces like this still unabashedly put their Twitter handle in their bio. There isnโt any excuse anymore.
Remember, when something in the news upsets you, you are *not obligated* to spend the next hour hunched over your phone reading live updates and social media hot takes.
You *can* stay informed without succumbing to this urge -- an urge deliberately conditioned into us for decades by the 24-hour news cycle and exploitative for-profit social media.
Step away from your screens, let your psyche absorb the blow, and read about it in a newspaper tomorrow morning if you like. You have permission!
If you want an ebook of some public domain work, either:
1. Check standardebooks.org before Gutenberg. They clean up books from Gutenberg with sane typography and print design.
2. Consider buying a "Dover Thrift Editions" version of the ebook. Many fly-by-night ebook "publishers" are turning a quick buck on selling you a Gutenberg edition. Dover is a real publisher, even in print, and their well-formatted ebooks of public domain works are usually under $4, or even less.
โI had very strong doubts that this text group was real, because I could not believe that the national-security leadership of the United States would communicate on Signal about imminent war plans.
โI also could not believe that the national security adviser to the president would be so reckless as to include the editor in chief of The Atlantic in such discussions with senior U.S. officials, up to and including the vice president.โ
Art-house goonDeveloper, designer, writer, and @wmbr DJ living in Cambridge, Massachusetts.Ex-@tinymixtapesยท webdev ยท vim ยท movies ยท music ยท uspol ยท design ยท typography ยท wordpress ยท