@AnthonyFStevens @Theriac @CloudyMrs @soren Please have a look. There are obvious issues, the allocation of revenue and taxes, the allocation of nominal interest rates on Scotland for ‘borrowings’ that are imposed by Enland and others.
The claim that ‘Xitter' demolished Murphy is itself laughable. I would suggest that for (different analyses - for that is economics) you might look at the IFS explanation. Then apply the levers an independent Scotland would have.