theres a long going argument in wrestling fandom that theres a ceiling for wrestling in terms of how many tv shows there can be, specifically how many wrestling companies can have their own tv shows going on.
to try and get across whats happening, imagine if there was only Big Brother, and that everyone who watched it was convinced that really theres only enough interest in reality tv to support one reality tv show.
Wrestling is a soap opera, or a reality tv show, or queer drag barely dressed people getting sweaty and fighting in a roleplay like way. There isnt really a ceiling on that as a medium, its just that for two and a half decades theres only been Big Brother.
in the UK when we had our own wrestling tv shows, grandmothers were one of the largest demographics of people who watched it because GILFs will be GILFs.
@siege I stumbled into an exhibition of wrestling stuff from ye olde days once! They had a load of costumes from Big Daddy and stuff on display, was really good!
@theogrin Yeah, if Lucha Underground had been properly funded and backed in a way that wasnt a total mess with people not getting paid i am convinced its take on wrestling as soap opera would have absolutely grown a whole new audience.
Sometimes it's about people fighting (and occasionally losing to) a mannequin.
Who says there has to be a cap? There might be a lot of different shows, but there are a lot of different fans, and some folks are in it for entirely different reasons. Heck, the same argument could have been (and has been!) made about sci-fi space operas, and while I'm agnostic in my likes -- Farscape and Battlestar Galactica are equally on my watchlist -- there's pretty much always room for more.
@siege Does it count if the sport at the center of the drama is different? I was reading an article about a reality show centered around F1 racing and thought to myself, “this is wrestling.”