The anti-technology bias in leftist social media circles is getting too much on my nerves. AI is not destroying anything. LLMs are not stealing any content. Tools and technologies lack agency and autonomy. If there is any type of entity that is ruining the Web, that is the Corporation.
For-profit corporations are led by people who must cater to the appetites of the market at every single moment at the risk of being fired by the administration or of the company going bankrupt. Of course, even within the confines of a market society, corporations can be more or less evil. But that can never serve as an excuse for being anti-technology.
Specially because all technologies are a result of a hybridization process where markets, universities, public administrations, and users participate to a lesser or greater extent. That extent is always determined by the balance of power in a given society in each single historical moment.
Taking this into account should lead us to evaluate beforehand the intrinsic affordances provided by a new technology, as well as the risks and advantages these offer, before making any judgements about the "goodness" or "evilness" of that same technology.
Unfortunately, what mostly happens is that people try to impinge their worldviews on what a technology IS - which is absolutely non-sense, since per se all technologies lack a fixed essence - based on the prevailing uses for that same technology in a given epoch (which, again, only reflects the current balance of power in a given society), instead of what that technology COULD BE. Even worse, in other cases, people just want to have the last word about what a new technology SHOULD BE. In a very dogmatic way, this also excludes all other existing or potential alternative uses for that technology.
For me, this is just another external sign that people are still very much locked into the proprietary and scarcity mindset that is so typical of capitalism.