@quinn No disagreement on the last point. I just don’t see the long-term need to hold on to any capitalist structures for those goals. We could have the commerce without the capitalism and local governance without centralised power.
I thought you were saying that certain forms of capitalism could somehow act as a bulwark against the excesses of a large centralised government. I don’t see a lot of evidence for that, especially given capitalists’ frequent tendency to subsume and dominate governments for their own ends.
If you need a second problematic system of exploitation and oppression to somewhat counteract your first one (and as a non-American I don’t really recognise the counterbalancing effect you’re referring to), it seems to me that you should probably try to get rid of both systems.
The “old woman who swallowed a fly” approach of increasingly compromised kludges feels like it’s been pretty conclusively debunked by now.