@skinnylatte where does Goat Hill and LOJ’s fall on that list for you?
for me Pizza My Heart is just a small step above national chains like Pizza Hut and Domino’s.
I genuinely enjoy Goat Hill at the original Potrero location and LOJ/Gioia/Pizzahacker is closest to a NY slice (the last two might qualify as fancy pizza?)
The rest of fancy pizza is Neapolitan around here, which I like but that’s its own animal.