@silverwizard @considermycat With BSG, the overall plot was both incoherent, and arbitrarily overrode the characters' intentions. I kept waiting for revelations of who was behind the arbitrary disasters, and no one was. They just kept throwing in disasters with the implication that someone was behind them, but no one was.
There was also some frustrating things where the showrunners, in interviews, drew equivalences that didn't seem equivalent at all.