Embed Notice
HTML Code
Corresponding Notice
- Embed this notice@sj_zero @Autumn @chadtoshinakamoto @rw
I think a lot of this debate has veered off into a tangent of whataboutery quite distant from my original point.
Abrahamic religion is uniquely narcissistic and genocidal in nature. That goes for Judajism, Christinanity and Islame alike. The primary reason for that is that the so-called sacred literature explicitly celebrates Abrahamic supremacy, exclusive claim to truth, and actively and vehemently vilifies any other system of belief, lifestyle or group. Moreover the 2,300 years of it's history right to the present day has repeatedly validated that fact. It's not exclusive to an institution but a feature which is reliably evident even in the common uninitiated reader/adherent.
To the limited extent some minor sects of Abrahamic religion may not have this feature, it's arguably due to outside influences from Pagan traditions such as Platonism and Hermeticism which focus more on the esoteric aspects of theology rather than literal and fundamentalist interpretations of what in reality are simply a set of historically farcical and culturally atavistic fairy tales. Either that or people are just cherry picking their favourite saccharine platitudes and leaving the obviously repugnant elements aside, while turning a blind eye to the consequences of continuing to promote the underlying ideological tradition.
Paganisms do not suffer from this mainly because there is no text mandating this sort of belief or behaviour. That doesn't mean some rulers of nation-states who were Pagan have not acted violently towards outsiders. Rather it was not done by the mandate of the religion, but instead for more mundane reasons such as acquisition of territory, material resources, and power, with religion acting merely as a ubiquitous cultural backdrop otherwise unassociated with that activity.
I could go on and debunk much of the rest of what you've said too, such as discussing the Islameic institution of Jizya and it's role in religious conversions and so forth, but it really just amounts to getting sidetracked by whataboutery that distracts from the actual point I was making.