It's the perfect thing for the mentally ill, power tripping piece of shit who hates you for some reason, won't tell you why, and wants you out right now. When you're kicked from a Discord server it vanishes from the list and so does the message history, so you can't see why either. The entire server is gone, and in the server in some "secret" admin room (which is visible with Ripcord/similar) they're too busy shit talking you.
I think why Discord is such a haven to unstable guild admins/mods is because it sets such a low barrier-to-entry for a set of people to have power over something. In the earlier years of the internet when someone would start a community they had to actually put their money and time into it, deploy a server or website, maintain it, and work through any surprises that come up. Those are things that would filter out many of the people that want quick fix of control over something, without ever contributing anything, and expect everything to be easy and free to them. Since Discord is architected as such a silo, if you have an unstable admin that wants a final 'fvck you', they can just nuke it. Meanwhile with a website or other common services, it's usually possible for other admins/mods to have backups and be able to restore it elsewhere (you can't just 'reimport' contents of a Discord guild, comparatively).
@charliebrownau@PhenomX6 I agree completely, but personally, I feel completely forced into using Discord, both by IRL friends and online friends. There are a few people with whom I’d lose contact completely if I stopped using Discord. I only have two friends whom I convinced to install Mumble, and even they usually prefer to use Discord for VC (even though Mumble has lower-latency and better sound quality). Not to mention that there’s no way in hell I could get them on IRC/XMPP.
The reality I’ve had to accept over the years is that normies don’t give a fuck about any of the things you mentioned, hell, even people with significant technical knowledge don’t always care. If we want people to use non-spyware open-source solutions, we have to make them just as convenient as Discord.
I think Matrix got pretty close to this goal, while I have my issues with how bloated it is, it’s also a huge improvement from Discord.
@charliebrownau@ThighHighSock@PhenomX6 The original Mumble client is good enough, no need for a soy client. Just let the normies on all the stuff they already destroyed, us chads will be on XMPP, IRC, Mumble, BBS, Newsgroups, Mailinglists, and all the other actually good stuff.
@charliebrownau@PhenomX6@ThighHighSock The internet was such a better place when you had to have a functioning brain in order to even use it. So yea, this barrier of entry, whether real or not, is really the bullet proof way of gatekeeping idiots out.
I sometimes get told "if you want people to use the darknet, XMPP, and all that, you'll need to make a satanphone crapp to make it as easy for them as clicking only 1 button.". I always reply, "why the fuck should I even make it easy for them to destroy the last good bits of technology!?".
No seriously, it's exactly because the internet has become easier to use (ironically, I actually find modern websoytes harder to use than the old websites) that caused us to have massive amounts of censorship and growing, fucking idiots destroying everything the brightest have created, and everything on one hand, and the tradcucks stopping us from fixing the problem before it's too late by saying "YOU'LL BE JUST AS BAD AS THEM!!" which are part of the problem on the other hand.
So yea, fuck all of them, let's keep the remaining few based technologies to just the nerds, and finally teach fellow nerds how to gatekeep and how to NOT make things easier to use (to automate the gatekeeping).
Just let the normies on all the stuff they already destroyed, us chads will be on XMPP, IRC, Mumble, BBS, Newsgroups, Mailinglists, and all the other actually good stuff.
That’s great, I like hanging out with chads and technically experienced people.
However, I also have friends in real life (and online) with whom I would like to stay in touch without using spyware apps like Discord. As I’ve posted before, I have close friends with whom I would completely lose contact without Discord. For this reason, it’d be really nice to have a convenient, privacy friendly, open-source, decentralized, Discord alternative.
@ThighHighSock@PhenomX6@charliebrownau As a workaround you could just set up a private XMPP server with closed registrations. From my own experience, those people will only use XMPP to talk to you, and use other stuff for everyone else. As long as you set it all up for them, they'll have no problem using it just for you.
@charliebrownau@ryo@PhenomX6 When I've tried to get normies on Mumble, they've always had the most trouble with the Audio configuration wizard, especially the Speex codec config part (I think the talking voice confuses them, and for whatever reason, people just don't read directions anymore).
I've had people set their mics to open transmission (or whatever it's called, I can't remember) because they couldn't understand the voice activity setup.
For the most part, they understand the server-username-port.
There is one. Can't remember the name of it, but something that ends with ",js", as it's a JS client. However, it's filled with bugs (what else do you expect from a JS soyware?), and I think OMEMO doesn't work on it either.
@ryo@PhenomX6@charliebrownau I think I’ll give it a try, but quite frankly, some of my friends would have trouble even installing an XMPP client (I wish I was kidding about that)
There must be a web front-end that I could set up though!
From my own experience, those people will only use XMPP to talk to you, and use other stuff for everyone else.
I’ve observed this phenomenon, with Mumble, my friends only used it to chat with me.
IRC The worst part is that IRC is super easy to use, people are just really fucking stupid. Just open a client, connect to IRC server and port and do /msg nickserv REGISTER <e-mail> <password>
The hardest part is concealing my IP address (most networks block Tor).
@ThighHighSock@PhenomX6@charliebrownau You'll be surprised by how many people find it difficult though. And yes, most IRC servers block Tor, which is just ridiculous. 076's IRC server doesn't block Tor though, and even if you don't use Tor, IP address is pretty well hidden, it's a feature of Ergo (IRC server software).
@ryo @charliebrownau@PhenomX6@ThighHighSock Yet, making it easier is a good approach. Because not everyone has this understanding of how it works technically, how to set it up, and how lately to maintain it. Look, just a rough example, if I want to listen to music I don't want to set up the proper frequency, calibrate speakers, and write a proper command in several lines. Because in the end, I will forget what I wanted to do.
@nk@PhenomX6@ThighHighSock@charliebrownau > Because not everyone has this understanding of how it works technically, how to set it up, and how lately to maintain it.
Which is exactly the point. Just like there are job interviews to gatekeep parasites out who would otherwise just leech money until the company goes bankrupt, there should be a barrier to entry to gatekeep idiots out who would otherwise demand destructive measures, government involvement, and mass surveillance to make it "easier" and "safer" for them to use.
Ease of use is nice and all, but ultimately, an Internet of just nerds (which is what you'll find on eepsites and to a much lesser extent onion sites) is a cool thing in itself.
The point is to keep people out who don't understand what's going on technically.
@ryo @PhenomX6@ThighHighSock@charliebrownau It was you who said “if you don't know how to set up and maintain it then hire someone who knows”. Now you changed your mind?
I was actually getting worried for a while that Fedi will get destroyed by the Twitfugees, and I'm glad to seeing Fedi fight back and actually fix the problem while it's still fixable, which also shows that I'm not the only one capable of doing so.
I'm assuming you mean Converse.js? https://conversejs.org/ There's also Movim: https://movim.eu/ Both do OMEMO. The latter option is fairly new and experimental, can be added as a PWA on mobile. If it's your own server for a few people, and there's reasonable trust that the server isn't compromised, TLS could be "good enough". (Plus if you run your own server, the TLS version support can be tightened and other hardening tweaks)
Normies are destroying our current clearnet by flocking to centralized, spyware services (such as Discord, Facebook, etc.) and thus creating a “network” effect where others are almost forced to use them.
Normies are enabling the corrupt financial system by refusing to use Monero, and insisting on credit cards. Even worse, many see cryptocurrency as “investment opportunities” and cause the prices to be volatile. They keep their coins in central exchanges, or even worse, investment apps such as Robinhood (which does not even allow you to send your bitcoins to an actual address).
Normies are destroying what little freedom the clearnet has left, by demanding that companies such as Cloudflare drop clients because they’re controversial.
Normies treat the Internet like real life, they make things less fun by being offended by people acting like retards for fun.
I’m not saying that any of these things are exclusive to normies, there are nerds cough cough trannies who do the same thing, but it’s a lot more common amongst normies.
A network of exclusively IT nerds would be much more pleasant. The i2p community demonstrates this pretty well!
@charliebrownau@nk@PhenomX6@ThighHighSock I do agree there are exceptions. There are good quality non-IT nerds and bad quality IT nerds out there, but both ways is just a tiny percentage. Good non-nerds can be thought of as newcomers with legit interest in IT willing to learn how to use computers the right way.
So I don't really mind non-nerds to be online if that's for them being willing to learn and adapt to the online culture, rather than them wanting to destroy it.
@ryo@PhenomX6@charliebrownau@nk I actually agree with this, the kinds of people who can't figure out IRC aren't like that solely due to a lack of technical experience, but due to apathy, and not wanting to learn.