@Bogusmeatfactory@MichaelKlamerus I don't see why it can't be both. They tiptoed into that territory with the teacup in Manhole, anyway, where it was both a teacup with a boat in it *and* a representation of Man's Yearning For Connection Amidst Chaos.
@MichaelKlamerus get ready to hear me rant about the nature of the star fissure and how it is a narrative device meant to physically represent the emotional rift between a father and son and not some REAL LIFE NATURAL PHENOMENA!
@Bogusmeatfactory@MichaelKlamerus I feel justified in asserting that a rational, science-driven explanation of a steam-powered tree elevator would increase my holistic enjoyment of the game.
@powersoffour@MichaelKlamerus this is, again, me getting crotchety about people's need to scientifically calculate and explain how everything works in Myst games with real-world science.
@Bogusmeatfactory@MichaelKlamerus I have no counterexamples to offer, merely the statement that an adherence to a self-consistent set of rules is something that I absolutely think helps with the immersion Myst provides.
@powersoffour@MichaelKlamerus I always like to stress that Myst games create a set of rules and play by them thoroughly. There is contextual reasons for almost everything, and how everything works follows the constraints of those rules, but in the end, they create the rules. They are not bound by the rules of the natural world we live in.
So we will have that steam powered tree elevator and we will understand how it works and love it even if it wouldn't work in real life!