@dzu The problem pointed out is not "there are issues in science", but sowing generalized distrust of science.
I have unfollowed male commenters for far less than what Sabine did, so while there may be some mansplaining happening, the problems in her take on science are sadly real.
Since I don’t follow Dave, your ending polarization ("either Sabine or Dave") is misplaced.
I’m in neither team, but I used to like Sabine’s videos. That changed and Dave’s criticism shows some of the reasons.