@feld I didn't give you any evidence, I no longer do point by point refutations of garbage, it convinces no one and requires reading garbage. I am not going to be upset if you reject my opinion on it completely because I didn't provide any evidence.

But I surely can say that if he makes his reputation on being an intellectual then the scenario that all his articles are bad (again not just middling but actually bad) but his books are good isn't worth entertaining either.