@dalias @cults3d The argument being made is one of fair use, and I'm not opining on whether that argument will pass legal muster, and frankly I hear different opinions from different lawyers so I'm just not going to play a lawyer on the internet.
I'm bringing in field of use not as a license consideration but as a social construct, which was why I used language of "values" and "I want" here.
I'm posting about how I feel about this use and not making a statement about what is legally permissible. I recognize that you are making an assertion about legality. I am not trying to tell you that you are wrong. I am not convinced that there is wide consensus on this matter, though. I do have concerns about unintended side effects of saying this is not fair use. In any case it's not what I was trying to talk about at all. I was only talking through my personal feelings about my own work.