@whitequark Do you have access to any of the confidential information here, or are you going purely based upon what is public?
That Person A is terrible does not mean that Person B is not terrible. That logs exist does not mean that information does not exist outside of the logs.
I have no ongoing association with either party in the concrete case. I have knowledge ofsome nonpublic information not from either party that I consider materially relevant but i would not consider sufficient to base a decision upon.