Conversation

Notices

1. Embed this notice
   Puniko ? (puniko@mk.absturztau.be)'s status on Saturday, 15-Mar-2025 22:42:09 JST Puniko ?

   • bastard pup from hell :ms_pup_flag: :therian:

   @Erpel@hai.z0ne.social @pup@yeen.town idk man. i'm not a fan of it not being optional (or at least opt-out)
   
   but i also wont jump the gun yet and yeet my instance because a) its not merged yet and b) the current list kinda agrees to which ones i wouldn't allow anyways
   
   but to the idea of this merge request: i think there should be tools to help admins to identify nazi music within their instances, i don't disagree on that point. but i think it should be up to the admin how to use those tools to moderate it. so at the very least, it should be opt-out, but better would be it being optional, best it would be a tool on the side of funkwhale itself. just my 2 cents

   • Embed this notice
     Puniko ? (puniko@mk.absturztau.be)'s status on Saturday, 15-Mar-2025 23:00:50 JST Puniko ?

     in reply to

     • bastard pup from hell :ms_pup_flag: :therian:

     @pup@yeen.town @Erpel@hai.z0ne.social i think a good way would also maybe be to make that wikidata query configurable by the admin in some way. this would make the feature more flexible and the changes to be made to the current code wouldn't even be that big

   • Embed this notice
     bastard pup from hell :ms_pup_flag: :therian: (pup@yeen.town)'s status on Saturday, 15-Mar-2025 23:00:53 JST bastard pup from hell :ms_pup_flag: :therian:

     in reply to

     @puniko@mk.absturztau.be @Erpel@hai.z0ne.social Yeah. I think there's a possibility they'll rethink this decision and implement it in a better way (optional and/or flagging to admins instead of outright rejecting content w/o oversight) if there's enough backlash, but OTOH they've been kinda dismissive so far... Still, might be worth a shot to leave a comment on the issue tracker.

   • Embed this notice
     Puniko ? (puniko@mk.absturztau.be)'s status on Saturday, 15-Mar-2025 23:15:57 JST Puniko ?

     in reply to

     • bastard pup from hell :ms_pup_flag: :therian:

     @pup@yeen.town @Erpel@hai.z0ne.social maybe i'm blind or didn't check deep enough, but from what i see in the MR, it doesn't actually delete any tracks does it? like what i see it hiding the tracks from api as well preventing them to get imported in the first place

   • Embed this notice
     bastard pup from hell :ms_pup_flag: :therian: (pup@yeen.town)'s status on Saturday, 15-Mar-2025 23:16:03 JST bastard pup from hell :ms_pup_flag: :therian:

     in reply to

     @puniko@mk.absturztau.be @Erpel@hai.z0ne.social Yeah - but it should also just flag the song for review or something. otherwise the moment it acts on a false positive and deletes a song or mangles its metadata (from what i can tell it also removes blacklisted artists from song credits metadata??) it's just going to get disabled entirely by the admin lol