Paul Cantrell
One of my least favorite genres of social media post:
EPISODE 1: At last, Foo Bar is politician who shares my personal ideology based on [three things they said]! The hero we’ve been waiting for!!
EPISODE 2: Oh no! Foo Bar is a horrible person because of [three other things they said]! Their poisonous ideology is completely explained by [deeply held stereotype about an entire political party]! I knew it all along!!
I just…ugh. Every part of this.
Paul Cantrell
Paul’s Very Short Analytic Notes on the Previous Post:
- Politicians are people.
- Political parties are coalitions.
- Both people and coalitions are messy and internally inconsistent.
- It’s best to treat politicians and parties as tools (not sports teams, not angels/demons, not heroes).
Paul Cantrell
@aubilenon
True enough! Yet somehow tethering one’s sense of personal identity to a sports team ends up doing less global damage.
Jesse Morris
@inthehands sports teams are also coalitions of people and also messy and internally inconsistent
Chairman Meow ᓚᘏᗢ 🦋🍉
@inthehands 100% agree with the first three, but I'd like to gently dispute that last one, because it's actually kind of dangerous.
Tools are things you have some modicum of direct control over.
Politicians and parties are not tools. They're capricious, unreliable and often actively hostile counterparties in an ongoing adversarial negotiation. Implying that voting any way "control" policy simply by voting, i.e. without additional activism, agitation, protest, etc, is demonstrably incorrect.
Paul Cantrell
@aubilenon
I mean, isn’t that the whole point of sports? That it’s just a game?
Jesse Morris
@inthehands Sure, but only because they don't matter.
Paul Cantrell
@darcher
“Implying that voters in any way control policy simply by voting, i.e. without additional activism, agitation, protest, etc, is demonstrably incorrect.”
It’s a really good fucking thing I don’t think that, then, isn’t it?
Chairman Meow ᓚᘏᗢ 🦋🍉
@inthehands ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ I'm just responding to "politicians and parties are tools" as a statement about how politics works.
And it's also a good thing we're just a couple of bozos chattiing about politics on social media, where nobody gives a rat's ass what either of us think. If we were actually trying to organize people, the way we thought about our goals, and the way we phrased our messages would actually matter, for a lot of reasons.
GNU social JP is a social network, courtesy of GNU social JP管理人. It runs on GNU social, version 2.0.2-dev, available under the GNU Affero General Public License.
All GNU social JP content and data are available under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 license.