Conversation

Notices

1. Embed this notice
   felsqualle (felsqualle@manitu.social)'s status on Sunday, 02-Jun-2024 14:44:03 JST felsqualle

   Alright, I am super-duper confused. I have an NTSC DVD ripped. I see the 3:2 pull-down pattern. And Handbrake just reports 23.9x FPS after the initial dump with MakeMKV.

   This is weird. I’d expect to have 29.97 FPS there, unless Handbrake already reads the proper flags from the MKV.

   Well, let’s wait for the first detelecine pass to finish.

   • Embed this notice
     felsqualle (felsqualle@manitu.social)'s status on Sunday, 02-Jun-2024 15:38:22 JST felsqualle

     in reply to

     • Tobias Hellgren

     @thanius That's interesting, a raw copy of the VOBs behaves exactly the same.

     So it is most likely a "soft-telecine" and Handbrake parses the appropriate flags?

   • Embed this notice
     felsqualle (felsqualle@manitu.social)'s status on Sunday, 02-Jun-2024 15:38:24 JST felsqualle

     • Tobias Hellgren

     @thanius That's what I'm going to check next - maybe MakeMKV doesn't do a "raw" copy...

   • Embed this notice
     felsqualle (felsqualle@manitu.social)'s status on Sunday, 02-Jun-2024 15:55:53 JST felsqualle

     • Tobias Hellgren

     @thanius Since it is an NTSC DVD, my expectation was to see the video file itself matching the proper NTSC frame rate. Examining the VOB with Hybrid reveals that the video itself is stored at 29.97 FPS.