Public
- Public
- Network
- Groups
- Featured
- Popular
- People

Our last hypothesis relates to a second double-standard experiment. Respondents were divided into three conditions: [Jewish / Indian / Catholic] Americans should do more to make [Israel / India / the Vatican] a more responsible country in the world. [Jewish / Indian / Catholic] Americans should be held accountable for [Israel’s / India’s / the Vatican’s] actions. The order in which respondents saw the two questions was randomized. The first question’s wording suggests that U.S. subgroups should take actions regarding foreign sovereigns. The second question’s wording suggests that U.S. subgroups are culpable for the actions of foreign sovereigns.

Download link

Our last hypothesis relates to a second double-standard experiment. Respondents were divided into three conditions: [Jewish / Indian / Catholic] Americans should do more to make [Israel / India / the Vatican] a more responsible country in the world. [Jewish / Indian / Catholic] Americans should be held accountable for [Israel’s / India’s / the Vatican’s] actions. The order in which respondents saw the two questions was randomized. The first question’s wording suggests that U.S. subgroups should take actions regarding foreign sovereigns. The second question’s wording suggests that U.S. subgroups are culpable for the actions of foreign sovereigns.
https://media.hachyderm.io/media_attachments/files/111/415/362/029/121/197/original/0f4331f0090a1779.png

Notices where this attachment appears

Embed this notice
Paul Cantrell (inthehands@hachyderm.io)'s status on Thursday, 16-Nov-2023 00:53:16 JST Paul Cantrell
in reply to

@jakelazaroff
I share these concerns. ADL really goes off the rails sometimes. (Ilhan Omar is my rep, so that example hits close to home!)
It's really worth looking at the actual study. As @raf said, they're clear about what they asked, and why. They're not quite asking the questions you posit. And despite using ADL resources in formulating some of the questions they did ask, their methodology answers a whole lot of the concerns you & I share.
Excerpts in screenshots:
@jdp23 @mekkaokereke

In conversation Thursday, 16-Nov-2023 00:53:16 JST from hachyderm.io permalink