Essay: Getting blocked on the Fediverse
I'm Usenet/Fidonet-old. I've spent my whole life debating on teh Intarnetz, both as a regular user, moderator or super admin - across such a vast set of services that I'm not sure I remember them all.
... and I think I'm getting blocked more often on the Fediverse than anywhere else, ever. I've been quite intrigued as to why, and I have started to form a hypothesis.
Usually a block will happen in a discussion when the other party _disagrees_ with you, and they have no interest in continuing the back'n'forth on who's right. Goodwin's law and all means any such discussion becomes quite heated, at that. Either you just walk away, or you block. My experience is that _most_ people just walk away - considering the other person having made a fool of themselves in the eyes of onlookers and that's enough.
... here ... it seems different. Now, I'm an undiagnosed GenX-who's-been-told-by-a-therapist-about-his-autistic-traits, and my "special interest" is knowing everything about whatever I become interested in - and I hold being factual above everything else. My other profile says "I read science papers instead of popular media headlines" or something to that effect.
And that seems to bug the hell out of some people here. My hypothesis is that this community, to a much larger degree than any other I've experienced, values "belonging to the in-group" higher than being factual. So in a discussion about a topic, if you point out a factual issue you get seen as not belonging to the "in-group" - but "the others". I have even seen someone claim I'm "probably a Tate-fan" which apparently had my sister absolutely furious for a good while when she read it :D
... because I pointed out something factually incorrect in a discussion.
cont ...
(1/2)