@Crystal_Fish_Caves
I like Swedish Saruman and can already picture that.
But what about the Hobbitses? Gonzo as Frodo? Or perhaps as Pippin? If the latter, Rizzo as Merry, or maybe switch the two? Who's least responsible of Gonzo and Rizzo? And who else can fill those giant hairy feet with them?
Sam the Eagle as Denethor? But who to play Boromir and Faramir?
Uncle Deadly as Grima Wormtongue, I think. Which then I guess means that Theodin has to be Rowlf?
And Crazy Harry as the one orc who blows up the outer ring wall of Helm's Deep.
I'm missing so many others. I worry there aren't enough Muppets to do it justice.
But Swedish Chef has to be Saruman. As befits your brilliance, I hereby present this humble rendering of what I see in my mind's eye as tribute.