Unlike threads, I genuinely want atproto to work. Multiple protocols working concurrently with different ideas, collaborating or competing, is good! There are and were plenty of good people that I genuinely admire that worked on this thing. There's enough shallowness and magical thinking in the end result, though, and not enough self-criticism or means of critical feedback to actually address the glaring abuse vectors, that I am pessimistic about bluesky and atproto becoming another healthy neighbor. When you're explicitly and uncritically calling it a marketplace in your whitepaper, I'm not interested.