Yeah I know there are die hard HP fans just creaming themselves over this game, but I am also on the fence. I'm pretty familiar with the books and movies so I can appreciate the details and such they put in, but despite all the visual touches and little details inside the castle that make things feel "lived in" and true to the series, there's 10 other things I could criticize so far about the game.

I don't dislike the game but right now it feels more like a visual novel with occasional tasks/QTEs/battles. It is kind of boring. I'd like the meat of the story to progress faster, and I'd like it if the "open world" had more to do.