Embed Notice

HTML Code

<blockquote style="position: relative; padding-left: 55px;"><section><a href="https://mastodon.scot/users/moh_kohn/statuses/115540282446832701">Alistair Davidson (moh_kohn@mastodon.scot)'s status on Thursday, 13-Nov-2025 13:14:47 JST</a><a href="https://mastodon.scot/@moh_kohn" title="moh_kohn@mastodon.scot"><img src="https://gnusocial.jp/avatar/103260-48-20251002231356.webp" width="48" height="48" alt="Alistair Davidson" style="position: absolute; left: 0; top: 0;">Alistair Davidson</a></section><article><p>I've been trying to express exactly this discomfort with modern interface design and especially LLM design and this lady nailed it back in *1993*</p><p>("A Small Matter of Programming", Bonnie A. Nardi)</p></article><footer><a rel="bookmark" href="https://gnusocial.jp/conversation/5857971#notice-11506987">In conversation</a><time datetime="2025-11-13T13:14:47+09:00" title="Thursday, 13-Nov-2025 13:14:47 JST">about 10 months ago</time> <span>from <span><a href="https://mastodon.scot/@moh_kohn/115540282446832701" rel="external" title="Sent from mastodon.scot via ActivityPub">mastodon.scot</a></span></span><a href="https://mastodon.scot/@moh_kohn/115540282446832701">permalink</a><h4>Attachments</h4><ol><li><label><a rel="external" href="https://gnusocial.jp/attachment/5450743">What interests
me about these scenarios is not that they make fantastic, unrealistic
promises, or that the instructions given by the
user are couched in simple English, or that they embody such a grand
vision. Rather, it is interesting
that it is the programmer who is to control all of the computational
magic. As Tesler says, programmers will endow computer-agents with
their basic capabilities, even meeting such exciting challenges as pro
gramming the computer to know what users will think before they
think it! By comparison, notice the relationship of the end user to the
computer; the end user is engaged in the most humdrum activities:
making queries regarding a phone conversation, asking the computer
to set up an appointment, requesting articles from the library.
Now contrast this vision of the computer-agent with what Alan Kay envisions for educational software:
children writing simulations of complex natural phenomena such as bi
ological and physical systems to better understand how they function.
Kay's colleagues have created a simulation construction kit for children
so that they can build their own simulations. The construction kit lets
children write simple scripts that model animal behavior. Using the kit
they can change parameters to see how changing conditions affect the
animal. This use of computers is an instance of what Tesler called the
"personal implement": the children are doing nothing more or less than
programming.</a></label><br><a href="https://media.mastodon.scot/media_attachments/files/115/540/277/514/715/628/original/d4ba53792057b6a5.png" rel="external">https://media.mastodon.scot/media_attachments/files/115/540/277/514/715/628/original/d4ba53792057b6a5.png</a></li></ol></footer></blockquote>

Corresponding Notice

Embed this notice
Alistair Davidson (moh_kohn@mastodon.scot)'s status on Thursday, 13-Nov-2025 13:14:47 JST Alistair Davidson
I've been trying to express exactly this discomfort with modern interface design and especially LLM design and this lady nailed it back in *1993*
("A Small Matter of Programming", Bonnie A. Nardi)
In conversationabout 10 months ago from mastodon.scotpermalink
Attachments
1. What interests me about these scenarios is not that they make fantastic, unrealistic promises, or that the instructions given by the user are couched in simple English, or that they embody such a grand vision. Rather, it is interesting that it is the programmer who is to control all of the computational magic. As Tesler says, programmers will endow computer-agents with their basic capabilities, even meeting such exciting challenges as pro gramming the computer to know what users will think before they think it! By comparison, notice the relationship of the end user to the computer; the end user is engaged in the most humdrum activities: making queries regarding a phone conversation, asking the computer to set up an appointment, requesting articles from the library. Now contrast this vision of the computer-agent with what Alan Kay envisions for educational software: children writing simulations of complex natural phenomena such as bi ological and physical systems to better understand how they function. Kay's colleagues have created a simulation construction kit for children so that they can build their own simulations. The construction kit lets children write simple scripts that model animal behavior. Using the kit they can change parameters to see how changing conditions affect the animal. This use of computers is an instance of what Tesler called the "personal implement": the children are doing nothing more or less than programming.
  https://media.mastodon.scot/media_attachments/files/115/540/277/514/715/628/original/d4ba53792057b6a5.png

Public

Embed Notice

HTML Code

Corresponding Notice