I often feel bemused and annoyed by little stories presenting technophobic settings as idyllic and preferable.
Without magic of some sort picking up the slack, it just makes it clear the author is healthy, not disabled in any way and hasn't yet had to deal with their flesh betraying them.
(Note that it's quite possible to use such a setting explicitly for the purpose of poking at these problems. That is not the presentation I am talking about.)
Stagnancy with no hope of any help for my issues and less or no escapism doesn't much sound attractive to me. It sounds worse than what I have.