Conversation

Notices

1. Embed this notice
   PhDog (dogfox@kpop.social)'s status on Saturday, 06-Dec-2025 02:35:29 JST PhDog

   I am going to start a new #kdrama tier list on this account. Instead of trying to maintain a "Table of Contents" post that just grows and grows and gets messed up, I will just define the tiers here and reply to this toot with reviews behind spoilers that give the shows rank and title.

   Tiers:
   Special S-rank: See review to come
   S-rank: Essentially perfect; high art
   A-rank: Truly excellent
   B-rank: Very good
   C-rank: Fine
   D-rank: Watchable but meh
   E-rank: Not good enough to finish
   F-rank: Trash

   • Embed this notice
     PhDog (dogfox@kpop.social)'s status on Saturday, 06-Dec-2025 02:35:29 JST PhDog

     in reply to

     It's all very well-done and the music is great and IU is wonderful but, IDK... I only made it to episode 6.

     It's very disjointed. Both in the narrative sense of being little vignettes and I am not quite sure where things are going half the time. (But in a messy xianxia kind of way, not an intriguing mystery kind of way.) But also content-wise. It can' seem to make up it's mind how bad things really are.

     Or something...Maybe I'll try again someday.

     #Kdrama