Embed this noticeAlex Gleason (alex@gleasonator.com)'s status on Friday, 28-Oct-2022 08:15:55 JST
Alex GleasonThe identity thing that Bluesky is trying to solve is not actually a real problem. Admin is a jerk? Start your own server. There's no user friendly way to be fully distributed, it's one or the other. The missing pieces are 1) an alternative to traditional DNS, 2) a professional paid fedi hosting service. THAT solves the real problems with federation.
Even in this solution that's supposedly better than Fedi, it relies heavily on the idea of hosting services. In fact it's required. Since every user has their own domain name, there's really no such thing as an "instance". It's a hosting service.
So that made me think my idea from a year ago was actually good and probably ahead of its time. I'm slightly mad about it and a little burned out.
@alex@bot >Even in this solution that's supposedly better than Fedi not relevant due to the networking effect. doesn't matter how technologically superior it is if there's no market or the creator doesn't produce an end-product (like pete)
Are you talking about tribes? Why did you shut it down anyway?
I actually really dislike that username system though, @alex@ gleasonator.com makes so much more sense than @alex.gleasonator.com. Well, maybe, I dunno.
I pitched Tribes to two investors, both turned me down. So I took a break to get back into Soapbox, got halfway through developing Groups then I got the call for Truth Social. So I shut everything down and started working on that. I'm still in this phase, but realizing something more needs to happen.
I don't actually know what tribes was about, I only heard about it recently. I do think instances make sense, because they're real communities with a coherent topic and identity. But otoh that does create division.