Conversation

Notices

1. Embed this notice
   Kelson (Tech and Testing) (kelsontalkstech@snac24.keysmash.xyz)'s status on Saturday, 16-Mar-2024 19:54:40 JST Kelson (Tech and Testing)
   Looks like #Threads still doesn't federate properly with #Snac2 or #GoToSocial.
   
   Which may be a feature as far as most GTS and Snac users are concerned!
   
   But I do want Threads to technically be able to federate with most/all other software that uses #ActivityPub, so it can be user/admin choice whether to accept connections from the giant instance...and more importantly, to cut down on the risks of vendor lock-in and EEE.
   
   And I hope more compatible systems will cut down on the "OK, my software federates with itself and Mastodon, I'm done" problem. In some cases there may be bugs on the smaller project's side, and fixing them might also fix issues talking to other small projects.
   
   GTS has already fixed a bug found by trying to federate with Threads, but there's still a bug on the Threads end preventing them from talking to each other.
   https://github.com/superseriousbusiness/gotosocial/issues/2491
   
   Key quote:
   If Facebook had an issue tracker for threads, someone could open an issue there. If threads was an open source project, we could look at the code and immediately know what's up, but... 🤷
   I might take a look at the Snac logs later and see if there's anything on this end breaking communication with Threads, or if it's all on the Meta side.
   
   • Embed this notice
     The Real Grunfink (grunfink@comam.es)'s status on Saturday, 16-Mar-2024 19:54:35 JST The Real Grunfink

     in reply to
     Hi, #snac author here. I've just read your message and tested following a Threads account, and the process seems to complete correctly, the log messages report the correct dialog and the account appears in my being-followed list (I still haven't received any message from that account, but it's still early, I think). What may have happened in your case is that the Accept message from Threads to your Follow request was lost or not sent for whatever reason, so for snac it's a follow not (yet) confirmed.
     
     Can you tell me what Threads account are you trying with? I'll investigate.
     
     Thanks for your help.
     
     
   • Embed this notice
     Kelson (Tech and Testing) (kelsontalkstech@snac24.keysmash.xyz)'s status on Saturday, 16-Mar-2024 19:54:39 JST Kelson (Tech and Testing)

     in reply to
     This is interesting: In Snac, I can see a Threads post boosted via a Mastodon account. It's a post from a few days ago on the account I tried to follow earlier. And according to the timeline and API, I am following them from Snac. But they aren't showing up on the list of people I follow.
     
     This suggests that Snac is able to interact with Threads posts, and is able to follow Threads accounts, but runs into trouble retrieving Threads profiles.
     
     Partial federation is a more interesting problem IMO than no federation, so now I really want to take a look at the logs!
     
     Tim Chambers repeated this.