Teri Kanefield
I'd like to add a bit more to what I said about this week's blog post:
https://mastodon.social/@Teri_Kanefield/112067724816108715
Invented Narratives and the Outrage Industry
It took me several years to understand what I was seeing.
At first, I thought the problem was Twitter algorithms. I thought that was the explanation for why what I was calling rage-inducing simplifications spread like wildfire.
1/
Teri Kanefield
People so appreciated what I did, that I kept doing it.
I basically followed behind the rage merchants and then showed the truth behind the rage-inducing simplifications.
I could do this because I am trained in the law and I have a good grounding in American legal and political history (for example, I researched and wrote my Making of America series).
I blamed Twitter. I didn't understand what was happening with Cable News shows because I don't watch them.
2/
Teri Kanefield
So it will be there as a resource.
Here is a fantasy: If people stop consuming rage content, it will stop being profitable.
It is a fantasy because it is too addicting.
Today's teachers and communications professors are teaching young people how to navigate information on the Internet and cable talk shows.
Similarly, people had to learn to evaluate written sources after the invention of the printing press.
9/
isotope239 🥸💻🇺🇦😣
@Teri_Kanefield I did a small experiment on myself recently. Mastodon is the only social media I follow and I wanted to get a taste of what 'corporate' centralized SM was like so I opened a Threads account. The contrast really opened my eyes; just a few minutes on Threads really does amplify that rage impulse, it's palpable. I assume this is probably true of the other platforms as well. It's obvious that it's healthier to simply avoid rage inducing platforms.
Teri Kanefield
It's a sign that something is wrong. That it's taking a toll on me.
I am sure it is taking a toll on a lot of people who are feeling anxious and unwell without knowing why.
Others are anxious because they are victims of the rage machine.
I am getting testy because I am completely disgusted by the rage machine.
I will put the finishing touches on my series, pin it to the top of each of my social media accounts.
8/
Teri Kanefield
Why indeed?
"What about Fox?" is actually a propaganda technique called whataboutism. It was made famous in the Soviet Union. No matter what criticism was leveled against the Soviet Union, the answer was, "what about racial segregation in America?"
Ironically enough, whataboutism is a way to avoid accountability and deflect blame.
'We may distort the truth, but they lie more," does not excuse the fact that we distort the truth.
(also I don't like being told what I should write 😂 )
6/
Teri Kanefield
I intend to continue my blog, but instead of responding to the latest rage, I will write about what interests me:
Who is included in 'we the people' and why?
How did our criminal justice system develop?
I'm also interested in voting rights history.
What I won't do anymore: offer commentary on the latest legal or political development.
Why? Because the moment I do, someone will tell me that there are never any real consequences and I will get testy and that testiness is a sign. . .
7/
Teri Kanefield
Over the past 6 months, reading the research of communications scholars, I began to understand.
As I came to understand, I grew testier and testier with what I was seeing.
When what felt like the millionth person would say to me, in an irritated voice, "Teri I agree with you in part, but the truth is that there are never any real consequences," I realized something was deeply wrong.
I wrote my FAQ page explaining. I tried sending people to the pages.
3/
Teri Kanefield
But it was an avalanche.
(Some people complained about the fact that I sent people to my FAQ pages. What am I supposed to do? Answer the same question 1,000 times? Pretend like that garbage has a place in serious discourse?)
I was getting testy because I could see a problem.
It was was dangerous groupthink: dangerous because when thousands of people say the same untrue thing in the same words, something nefarious is happening.
4/
Teri Kanefield
One feature of fasicsm is group chants.
How is "There are never any real consequences!" chanted by tens of thousands of people in chorus not a group chant?
I can guarantee that if I wrote this on Twitter, someone would say, "But there ARE never any real consequences."
On Mastoston there is 1 in 10 chance that I'll get that comment 😂
An improvement? I don't know.
At least a half dozen people responded to my post with irritation asking, "Why are you focusing on MSNBC and not Fox?"
5/
GNU social JP is a social network, courtesy of GNU social JP管理人. It runs on GNU social, version 2.0.2-dev, available under the GNU Affero General Public License.
All GNU social JP content and data are available under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 license.