The old brick. Discoloration is real. Scratches of different depth. There's a variety of dents and holes with missing material. Edges are less round than in the new one but still rather ok. Clutchpower is also perfectly ok: the brick functions as a new one.
https://files.mastodon.online/media_attachments/files/112/885/652/644/684/472/original/c9dbe246adc3b9ec.jpeg