engels_doodle.jpg

Notices where this attachment appears

1. Embed this notice
   pistolero (p@fsebugoutzone.org)'s status on Friday, 19-Jul-2024 20:04:59 JST pistolero

   in reply to
   @strypey @SilverDeth @not_br549 @jeffcliff @sj_zero
   
   > As an anarchist, surely you know that "antifa" and "left" are categories that overlap, but are far from the same thing.
   
   Well, I said he was "probably a commie", you said "probably not a leftist"; you've used the terms interchangeably.
   
   They can call themselves whatever they want and I, like Eazy-E before me, will call a spade a spade and get paid.
   
   :eazye: Semantics are a spook anyway. :stirner:
   
   > There are also plenty who don't.
   
   Antifa is an attempt to rebrand commies to sound less gulag-friendly. I don't know of anyone using the Antifa™ brand that are not also ancoms (let alone a large enough number that they can no longer be dismissed as rounding error). They love clipping words, the Comintern probably mandates it. I think they should put quotes around the "an" in "ancom" but I'm not going to argue terminology.
   
   How they self-identify isn't relevant to me. The primary activity of European anarchists and socialists has been and continues to be bitter arguments over terminology. Lenin is writing a tortured essay trying to explain how owning a cat isn't counterrevolutionary. You know the "USSR wasn't real communism" meme, but have you read Mussolini's last interview before he was assassinated? The interviewer asks him about the USSR and Mussolini responds by dismissing the question, on the grounds that the USSR "isn't real socialism". We've got this doodle Engels made, it's the source of the famous caricature of Max Stirner, but the actual drawing is some sort of shouting match, a bunch of useless dickheads that are more insistent on terminology. I was innoculated against this at a very young age when, some time around the time I saw my thousandth tedious essay about how one thing or another was "not punk rock" in a poorly xeroxed zine, I realized that it was a complete goddamn waste of time and that if you let them, these people will spend all of their time on it. Fine, let them, as long as they don't do it near me. "What is punk rock? It's not music or the liberation of music from the labels and the radio stations, DIY ethos, a culture of participants instead of bystanders, it's about none of that: punk rock is about arguing incessantly about the definition of 'punk rock' and the music is getting in the way, please unplug those amps until you have all understood and accepted the error of your ways and started using the words in a way that I approve."
   
   The terms that I use are for me to use. I don't self-identify as an idiot but people call me an idiot without my permission. I don't need anyone's permission to call them a commie.
   engels_doodle.jpg