12 While the “butt and fart” books may not on their face have a clear “idea” or “viewpoint,” the record reveals that they were removed because Defendants did not want readers to have access to books with pictures of naked bodies. Defendants believe that these books promote “grooming” by depicting children displaying their naked bodies to “various individuals, some of whom are adults.” I see access to these images—and what Defendants say that they allegedly promote—as a viewpoint sufficient to support an unconstitutional motivation under Campbell. Both of my colleagues disagree, however, so our holding does not require the return of those books. Nor does it require the return of In the Night Kitchen or It’s Perfectly Normal, for the same reasons.
https://assets.journa.host/media_attachments/files/112/572/768/684/419/874/original/1d9c48780054f9cf.png