Notices by Renee DiResta (noupside@saturation.social)

You can change the title of this chart and - with the exception of Orban - this process has been essentially identical, featuring the same people, for the last five years.

Online rumors as propaganda, advancing the goals of a political machine.

We chronicled how this worked in election 2020…and got investigated by Jim Jordan in retaliation.

New from me, and unexpectedly timely with the Zuck announcement. 🙃 This is an essay about “working the refs” - trying to make the people who make the rules advantage your side - and what happens if that becomes impossible.

Ref-working has influenced content moderation policies for a long time; platforms respond to pressure, as we saw yesterday! Since policies shape norms & influence what goes viral, ppl have strong opinions ab these shifts.

https://www.noemamag.com/the-great-decentralization

“RFK Jr: Maybe A Broken Clock Is Right Twice A Day?”
“Yes, Children’s Health Defense Lies Hurt Kids BUT…”

This media coverage framing is about to seep into a confirmation hearing, where it’ll be used to imply that pesky medical “experts” opposed to RFK are the *real* unreasonable ones. “We all know the status quo is bad, why do you hate change?”

This is a rhetorical trick implying a binary. It’s not “RFK vs status quo”!

*American kids deserve a qualified leader. Pick the best for them.*

A bit ago I joined Ryan Holiday to talk ab online manipulation & smear campaigns, among other things. He wrote the 📕 “Trust Me, I’m Lying: Confessions of a Media Manipulator” ab his own work in PR & manipulated narratives. If you’re interested in the Blake Lively story, listen. The tactics are almost identical bt entertainment & politics — it’s easy to smear someone in an age of online rage mobs & vitriolic factions!

https://dailystoic.com/the-new-age-of-media-manipulation-renee-diresta/

kakistocracy, noun

The 2024 Freedom on the Net report is out. It includes analysis of generative AI in elections globally, and actual attempts at censorship around elections — ie, governments using their power to silence dissidents, or parties manipulating the info space

https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-net/2024/struggle-trust-online

“I saw people on television talking about it”

As RFK Jr prepares to “”address the nation”” today, I hope media who cover the pseudoevent note that he put out a 10 min video on Instagram yesterday articulating the long-standing anti-vax talking points that he downplayed for broader appeal: stuff about the “package inserts”, “no safe vaccines”, “the schedule”, & the “right to choose” whether to vaccinate your kids against polio. This is what his run has always been about. He is gunning for a Trump CDC or HHS appointee role to “fix” vaccines.

Anyone familiar with longstanding antivax tropes will recognize all this immediately. “Package inserts”, in antivax land, supposedly reveal all of the terrible side effects and evil ingredients. Doctors are keeping this from you because they are BOUGHT!!! Except all this info is available online, you can ask the doctor for it, and every medication on the market has disclosures like this. A possible side effect is not a frequent side or even a bad side effect. Just pure paranoid innumeracy.

I wrote a book about how this works! Buy it for your parents…

@wfryer thank you! I really don’t know what to do about Twitter at this point. It’s a tough call bc the attacks are vicious and impactful at times. Building up community elsewhere is also very important.

“Plaintiffs Lack Standing to Sue Over Government Jawboning When Their Evidence is Based on Vibes–Murthy v. Missouri”

https://blog.ericgoldman.org/archives/2024/06/plaintiffs-lack-standing-to-sue-over-government-jawboning-when-their-evidence-is-based-on-vibes-murthy-v-missouri.htm

“This anti-accountability movement brought to mind the horrible abuse heaped upon the Stanford Internet Observatory, which has had to retrench its research efforts because the MAGA movement branded it as part of the “censorship industrial complex.” Knocking SIO out of the accountability industry might cheer the MAGA base, but the House Republicans’ role in targeting SIO is actually a way worse form of censorship than anything the Biden Administration allegedly did in this case.”

My Wikipedia bio got locked down, so the next front is brigading Amazon. This Twitter Files superfan explicitly called for 1-⭐️ reviews - and his followers delivered. Some left bad reviews, others upvoted them 80+ times. “Dunk on DiResta" — her allies at Langley are controlling the narrative! (Also dunk on Fauci while you're at it.)

This is the asymmetry of passion in action... these groups enthusiastically brigade their enemies while it's v hard to get normal folks to counterspeak or act

Threat intelligence indicators also released by Meta suggest that not all companies are acting to intervene.

So in the above piece for MIT Technology Review, we point out why disclosures matter, and why data sharing is key.

I’m also going to re-up this one from earlier in the week, which was an SIO analysis of threat indicators from late last year - some platforms were slow to act.

https://cyber.fsi.stanford.edu/io/news/how-coordinated-inauthentic-behavior-continues-social-platforms

“A SPECTER IS HAUNTING right-wing dissident Substackers—the specter of Renée DiResta.”

My book is reviewed in The Bulwark today — and it’s a very entertaining read! 😊

https://www.thebulwark.com/p/influencers-bullshitters-losing-shared-reality

Last week was the 1st disclosure from OpenAI confirming that state-linked actors were using their tools for influence operations —something that’s always been a question of when, not if, if it would happen.

But we also got a disclosure from Meta, incl some of the same ops — bc after you create content you have to spread it. Theirs showed that this time, it got no pickup…

https://www.technologyreview.com/2024/06/08/1093356/propagandists-are-using-ai-too-and-companies-need-to-be-open-about-it/

New work on SIO blog: “How Coordinated Inauthentic Behavior Continues on Social Platforms”

We looked at threat indicators that Meta posted in its Q3 2023 transparency report (attributed to 🇨🇳 , 🇷🇺 , & 🇮🇷 ), noticed that some platforms had not taken down attributed accounts, found more accounts that appeared to be linked, and followed to see what happened.

https://cyber.fsi.stanford.edu/io/news/how-coordinated-inauthentic-behavior-continues-social-platforms

I feel like I hit some age, maybe 35, where forever after every minor cold has turned into some kind of long-lasting infection. My kids are better in two days, and I suffer for two weeks.

🧵 I wrote ab the “is Signal secure?” manufactroversy on X. The Guardian wanted an explainer on why Elon & Jack were “concerned” about Signal. The answer, though, has nothing to do w/Signal’s product. It was part of an extended fight over whether woke NPR should be defunded & the CEO fired. Why? Because the CEO of NPR is on the board of Signal; by the Transitive Property of Bad People, Signal is thus compromised.

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/article/2024/may/18/npr-elon-musk-signal