This has always been a huge part of the problem with Apple's strategy here -- you're asking app developers to become faceless back-end processors for information to be mined by Siri. If the future of phones is using AI assistants, then the future of apps is to be grist for the mill. Hard to envision a lot of app developers being willing to work extra hard to be fed into the wood chipper. https://mastodon.social/@stroughtonsmith/114122893893005514
Just to reiterate something we discussed on @upgrade few weeks ago:
* Apple got all the benefit of announcing these features last June, when it needed to change the narrative about it embracing AI
* Now when nobody's really looking they announce they won't ship till iOS 19, they'll take a few shots but it's not going to undo what the 2024 PR and marketing blitz did
* I'm sure that Apple executives are comfortable making that trade
* We must be even more skeptical about WWDC 25 announcements
Enough is enough. It's time for the era of exclusive app stores and tight control to end. Apple has already solved this problem. The Mac is the way forward.
Why "utter contempt?" It's saying that, even if I know for a fact that I want to give a particular app permission, macOS will treat me a like a child and keep asking me. Because Apple doesn't believe I am qualified to grant permanent permission to any app.
Another sign that the people in charge of security and privacy features at Apple are out of control and that nobody who stands up for user experience is being heard.
I will share some good news. I haven't verified it lately, but it's my understanding that permissions now survive a system migration? Meaning that when you migrate, you won't have to approve 200 dialog boxes and check boxes in Settings to get apps up and running. That's a win for the users, I guess.
Meanwhile I suppose I should schedule some weekly 'authorize my apps to do what I installed them to do' time in my calendar...
Here's a thing I noticed today. macOS Sequoia changes how non-notarized apps are handled on first launch. I couldn't override by doing the control-click > Open > yes really Open dance. Instead, I had to go to the Settings app, to the Security screen, and click there to allow it to open. At which point it asked me AGAIN if I wanted to open it, and then had to put in my password!
I get the impulse about making it harder to socially engineer bad apps from opening, but... this is ridiculous.