@evan I don’t mean blame in a “who is at fault in a proper root cause analysis” sense (though that is also important) but in a “who will the press, government, and broader zeitgeist blame” sense.
@evan The other interesting question about how it maps to fediverse is who gets blamed for privacy problems more generally. We all know email is a privacy mess but no one blames “the email company”; when Fedi inevitably has problems, will people blame ActivityPub, Eugen, Zuck, …?
@evan Yeah. I’m sure the “we and only we can monetize” played a role too (especially at the exec level), but many rank and file genuinely believe a story that goes something like: 3rd-party extensions require data access; data access to FB-like data (more sensitive than Twitter!) at FB-like scale means some 3rd-party will inevitably abuse; FB will inevitably get blamed for that abuse no matter what safeguards were in place; so the risk is too high. And that is hard to argue with!
@evan Talk to FBers and their internal story is that it was essentially impossible to do this in a way that complied with their own sense of impending EU privacy rules. I’m not sure that was their primary motivation, but Cambridge Analytica really was an abuse of this vector so it isn’t completely implausible.
@wwahammy@simon@dalias@matt@danilo@maria dunno, man, it's generating working python and shell that Does Shit for me. Maybe my scripts count as bullshit to you, or maybe the time I saved is bullshit to you, or maybe it's bullshit that I didn't hire somebody on fiverr to write them for me, but they're pretty useful bullshit to me.
@dalias@simon@matt@danilo@maria “which the user has a mental model for potentially being a party they do or don't trust” lol/sob, they absolutely don’t have that mental model, that’s why so much disinfo was quite effective pre-llm.
There’s a fair critique that the use of first person pronouns and conversational style make it even harder for people to do that analysis. But it was pretty hard for most people already.
Programmer turned lawyer and community guy. Current: Tidelift, Creative Commons, OpenET, California HDF, 415/94110, dad.Previously: Wikimedia, Mozilla, Open Source Initiative, GNOME, LegOS, Duke, 305/MIA, more.