I am actually pessimistic about this idea. The Eternal September is here to stay. It's in people's nature to selfishly think everything is about them and that their opinion is both unique and desired. For every person who learns when to reply and when to… not reply… 10 more just joined who haven't learned.
The tools need to reflect this imbalance.
I *also* choose to lower my expectations, but for every person who has learned to lower their expectations, 10 more just joined who haven't learned.
@annika I'd be really curious to see a take at federate social media that both A) emphasizes specific communities that are capable of defining norms and allows users to feel confident that those norms will be respected when they want them to be, and B) still creates the possibility for broadening horizons and encountering strangers. But it'd have to be something fundamentally different than fedi and in this space we need more tools to protect against followers-of-followers-of-followers
@Hyolobrika A particular problem is people posting about a struggle and getting unsolicited advice. Federation can also result in partially visible threads, so you end up with a hundred replies saying the same unwanted and unneeded thing. That's a frustrating situation that Mastodon doesn't help mitigate (e.g. with reply controls)